Trophy Case

Prize Ideas for Adults Scavenger Hunt & Treasure Rewards

Planning Tips Dec 1, 2025

When it comes to increasing participation and attendance at recreational events, we at Goosechase have learned from years of organizing interactive scavenger hunts that players respond more to prizes than promises of bragging rights alone.

Whether your event is a casual outing, a corporate team-building activity, or a large-scale treasure hunt, a thoughtful treat or prize can make all the difference.

Regardless of what your most sportsmanlike competitors might tell you about "challenging themselves in the spirit of competition", we all know the truth: sometimes it takes a few carrots to get the donkey moving.

Read on as we explore some different elements you might want to consider when choosing which prizes to give away at your next competitive event.

Why Prizes Increase Event Attendance and Participation

Before you can award any prizes, you need participants! So, first things first, an explanation of how and why prizes are great incentives to drive registrations and attendance.

incentives-carrots-goosechase

In their best-selling book Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything, Authors Stephen Dubner and Steven Levitt assert that incentives, both the reward or penalty varieties, are central to driving human behaviour.[1]

By offering scavenger-hunt prizes for adults, prizes for scavenger-hunt winners, or unique treasures, participants are motivated to participate fully and creatively.

Stephen and Steven classify incentives into three forms:

  1. economic, which provide a gain or loss in material;
  2. social, which provide a gain or loss in reputation; and
  3. moral, which provide a gain or loss in conscience.

The Freakonomics model is a good way to start thinking about the types of prizes you may want to award to your competition winners and participants.

Event Prize Ideas with Strong Economic Incentives

  • Gift certificate for online retailers
  • Electronics/products
  • Tickets to local sports team's next game
  • Gift certificates to local or chain restaurants

Event Prize Ideas with Rewarding Social Incentives

  • The winning team gets party favours, goodie bags, or glow sticks.
  • Friendly bets, such as the losing team having to wear outrageous hats of the winning team's choice for a week, and costume challenges for the best performance.
  • Names engraved on a trophy or keychain with the company logo.

Event Prize Ideas with Rewarding Moral Incentives

  • Donation made toward a charity of winner’s choice
  • Gift certificates to a local restaurant or store that specializes in sustainable or locally-sourced products
  • Branded merchandise in support of sponsoring organizations

Matching Event Prizes to Your Event Goals

Similar to the advice we give in our 3-part guide to office scavenger hunts, we recommend you choose prizes that align with your overall event objectives.

choosing-prizes-goosechase

Goal: Attracting Participants

For a public engagement event where your goal is to attract as many participants as possible, a prize with a direct economic incentive, such as a gift certificate to a popular retailer or a high-value cash prize, can help you attract the broadest possible audience.

Goal: Participant Interaction

For team-building, icebreakers, or other friendly competitions where your goal is to drive interactions amongst participants, setting up social incentives in your prizes can be just the ticket. Awarding prizes, such as large quantities of food and drinks, will encourage the winner(s) to immediately share them with other participants, fostering positive feelings and further strengthening social bonds. Look no further than fantasy sports leagues for further inspiration for friendly, competitive social incentives, such as the losers having to wear the other team's jersey for a day, or the winners being memorialized on a makeshift trophy or plaque.

Offer prizes like vouchers, glow in the dark toys, or high-value treasure to draw a large audience. Encourage team collaboration with scavenger-hunt prizes such as necklaces, novelty items, or party-game baskets.

Goal: Fundraising

If you are raising money for a charity or non-profit organization, tap into your audience's sense of moral incentives when structuring your prizes. The tried-and-true 50-50 fundraiser format, with half of the entry fees going to the charity and the other half to the winners of a raffle or competition, serves as both a moral and an economic incentive.

Participants will feel more justified in paying an entry fee knowing that part of the funds are going towards a good cause. Incorporate thoughtful prizes, such as treasure-hunt ideas or prizes for scavenger-hunt winners, or donate incentives to motivate giving.

Not-so-Grand Prizes to Maintain Participation and Engagement

Have you ever found yourself the only person left out of a conversation about a popular TV show? Having just one grand prize for an event being run over several days or longer (such as a convention or festival), can feel the same way for latecomers to your event.

fall-behind-goosechase-1

Even if your grand prize is out-of-this-world across all three incentive categories, guests might feel discouraged from participating if they think they have no shot at catching up.

A good way to compensate for this is to include alternate ways to win prizes. Award the most creative submissions. Or the submission with the most likes. This way, players who clearly wont be in contention for the grand prize still have incentives to take part.

Specifically for scavenger hunts run on GooseChase, the ability for organizers to award bonus points to creative or stand-out submissions gives organizers the final say on many aspects of the leaderboard. The inclusion of "spirit awards" remind all participants that the event is not all about winning, and motivates casual competitors to enjoy taking part.

Celebrate and Reward All Participants, Not Just The Winners

Your role as an organizer is successful if your guests leave your event with positive memories, whether or not they won the competition.

celebrating-participants-goosechase

Although not strictly considered "prizes", if your event requires participants to be active, make sure to have plenty of food and refreshments ready to greet guests as they regroup on the other side of the finish line.

When the event is over, for triumphant champions and gracious competitors alike, organizers putting on a spectacular closing ceremony will be appreciated by all. For Goosechase games, we’ve found that putting together a highlight reel creates a celebratory atmosphere that perfectly wraps up the show while recognizing all who were involved.


Check out the GooseChase blog for additional event planning and scavenger hunt resources. If you're an organizer seeking a tried-and-true competitive activity to integrate into your next group outing, visit the GooseChase how-it-works page to learn more about the platform and trying creating your first game for free!


  1. Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything - Speed Summary ↩︎

What is Goosechase?

At Goosechase, experience is everything. Originally inspired by scavenger hunts, Goosechase is an online platform that enables organizations and schools to engage, activate, and educate their communities through delightful interactive experiences. Sign up and try creating a free recreational Experience, or check out our Pricing!

Tags

Eric Chiang

Product Manager. An avid Hans Zimmer fan who cycles more than he walks, Eric brings his experience-creation background to Goosechase, shaping thoughtful product experiences. Armed with a new slow cooker, he’s always up for swapping recipes.